Post by Adele on Jul 17, 2012 22:45:15 GMT -5
Hello Girls!!!!
Welcome to your Eleventh Judging Session. Let's start the judging now
Adele: I think the photo definitely has the commercial value, but to me it's a little bit safe, Ash.. I'm not sure if I'm going to remember this. I think the angle especially on your upper lip didn't stand out much. But you look beautiful!!!
Nat: I'm inclined to agree with Adele. You'll be lucky to have those "past photoshoot" points helping you out, because I'm rather bored by this. I don't think your lips are prominent here, and you have an accurate coloring but this just comes across as safe. Sorry!
Amanda: This is cute, but it isn't memorable. I'm going to agree with Adele and Nat - it's safe and it isn't memorable. I'm not going to remember this one when stocked up against your prior shoots. Plus, I don't see you owning the product - your lips aren't my focus of attention, your eyes are. You've done well in this cycle... but this one is just good at best for me. You can do better here, I know it!
Lee: Unfortunately, this is pretty mediocre. I mean there's nothing great about the look, the clothing or the styling. I would say this is worse than safe. It just seems like you got really lazy when choosing a picture for this shoot!
Adele: I think the color is suitable for 'Stunner'. I love the dramatic value in this photo. From the big hair to the way you pose. Love the eye-contact. Good job, Emmy...
Nat: I think "stunner" was a great lipstick for you because you look stunning! Absolutely fantastic this week, especially with the angling. The only thing I have a slight problem with is your gorgeous hair- it's taking away from your lips a bit! You still did a great job though.
Amanda: I liked this back in Cycle 9 enough to rank you above that [censored] Ayumi, and I like this same shoot once again... and even more than last time. Your hair is flawless, but like Nat I think it's distracting from the lips a bit. You are smizing, and the lips are really pretty. I'm not sure if I will remember what product this is FOR, though - I'm more apt to remember the image itself because it's that freaking gorgeous. The angle... everything, really. I love it, Emmy. Congrats
Lee: Every time I try and critique this photo my internet dies and I have to restart ugh! So I'm gonna be quick! I don't like this as much as the other judges. your facial expression seems empty (something about you hmm), but the eyes are staring into my soul and I can't look away!
Adele: Kate.. I'm not too sure about your hairstyle. I think you look a little bit tired in the photo especially your eyes. The color of lipstick looks good on you. Your lips looked good too. But like I said before, more energy would be better.
Natalie: Kate, I'm sorry, but this photo lacks a lot of energy. I think you're showcasing the product really well here, but I wish you were more enthusiastic! You look a bit older than you normally do, and I don't like this hair style for a Cover Girl. Sorry Kate!
Amanda: Yeah, I'm going to agree. You look pretty weathered here, and the lack of energy is hurting you a lot. I wouldn't notice this if it were an ad. Your earring is distracting. I'm okay with the hairstyle, but it seems a bit too... "sophisticate" for CoverGirl - too elegantly old-fashioned, really. I also see some blush here... or maybe that's your skin. I'm really not sold on this at all, Kate. Sorry... :/
Lee: This is very poor. I hate everything about it!
Adele: I think you just redeemed yourself from that horrible Covergirl Ad during your original cycle. The color looks nice on you. I like the styling. I think you looked fun & fresh here. Overall, I like it
Natalie: Katy, you've peaked this week and it's the right week to do it. You look fierce here, and your lips are absolutely gorgeous. Your shiny hair helps bring out your lips- I have no problems with this. Great job!
Amanda: Yeah, let's forget about what happened in cycle 9 here. This most definitely blows that all the way to the end of the universe. Your lips are stealing the show, even with your gorgeous hair being a little too... sparkly, for lack of a better word. Really, your hair almost steals the show, but it doesn't - I really don't have much else to add. It's young, it's fresh, it's easy, it's breezy, it's beautiful, and it's CoverGirl. Congrats on making the finals
Lee: I don't understand all of the love for this to be honest lol. Your eye make-up is very dark and it looks like you have bags under your eyes. Your lips are weird and I hate the random hand on your shoulder. I guess you shouldn't worry if everyone else loves this though.
Adele: What happened to your left arm? It looks like it was twisted or something. Really distract me. But the Advertisement version is really good. I love the color of the lipstick on your lips. The styling is great and you eye-contact is strong. Overall, except the arm, I'm a fan of this photo
Natalie: I agree with Adele; I'm not so much bothered by the hand as I am with the arm. No matter, this is still a great photo because your lips stand out a lot. Your hair made a vast improvement from last time, and you just look like a model in general. Not bad this week, Monica!
Amanda: Good, but not great. Your lips are front and center and that's good news, but that arm is distracting - your nail polished fingertips aren't. I like your hair (yeah you've done this look before xD) and it's definitely suitable for CoverGirl... but that arm. It looks unnatural and... makes it feel a lot less like a makeup ad. This could be better, but it isn't awful!
Lee: This 100% by far the best Covergirl photo this season. How the hell are people annoyed by your arm if nobody was annoyed with Katy's hand? At least this one has a great styling. Obviously going for a sexy look it fits the picture perfectly. I'm angry nobody else loves this like I do!!!!
Welcome to your Eleventh Judging Session. Let's start the judging now
Adele: I think the photo definitely has the commercial value, but to me it's a little bit safe, Ash.. I'm not sure if I'm going to remember this. I think the angle especially on your upper lip didn't stand out much. But you look beautiful!!!
Nat: I'm inclined to agree with Adele. You'll be lucky to have those "past photoshoot" points helping you out, because I'm rather bored by this. I don't think your lips are prominent here, and you have an accurate coloring but this just comes across as safe. Sorry!
Amanda: This is cute, but it isn't memorable. I'm going to agree with Adele and Nat - it's safe and it isn't memorable. I'm not going to remember this one when stocked up against your prior shoots. Plus, I don't see you owning the product - your lips aren't my focus of attention, your eyes are. You've done well in this cycle... but this one is just good at best for me. You can do better here, I know it!
Lee: Unfortunately, this is pretty mediocre. I mean there's nothing great about the look, the clothing or the styling. I would say this is worse than safe. It just seems like you got really lazy when choosing a picture for this shoot!
Adele: I think the color is suitable for 'Stunner'. I love the dramatic value in this photo. From the big hair to the way you pose. Love the eye-contact. Good job, Emmy...
Nat: I think "stunner" was a great lipstick for you because you look stunning! Absolutely fantastic this week, especially with the angling. The only thing I have a slight problem with is your gorgeous hair- it's taking away from your lips a bit! You still did a great job though.
Amanda: I liked this back in Cycle 9 enough to rank you above that [censored] Ayumi, and I like this same shoot once again... and even more than last time. Your hair is flawless, but like Nat I think it's distracting from the lips a bit. You are smizing, and the lips are really pretty. I'm not sure if I will remember what product this is FOR, though - I'm more apt to remember the image itself because it's that freaking gorgeous. The angle... everything, really. I love it, Emmy. Congrats
Lee: Every time I try and critique this photo my internet dies and I have to restart ugh! So I'm gonna be quick! I don't like this as much as the other judges. your facial expression seems empty (something about you hmm), but the eyes are staring into my soul and I can't look away!
Adele: Kate.. I'm not too sure about your hairstyle. I think you look a little bit tired in the photo especially your eyes. The color of lipstick looks good on you. Your lips looked good too. But like I said before, more energy would be better.
Natalie: Kate, I'm sorry, but this photo lacks a lot of energy. I think you're showcasing the product really well here, but I wish you were more enthusiastic! You look a bit older than you normally do, and I don't like this hair style for a Cover Girl. Sorry Kate!
Amanda: Yeah, I'm going to agree. You look pretty weathered here, and the lack of energy is hurting you a lot. I wouldn't notice this if it were an ad. Your earring is distracting. I'm okay with the hairstyle, but it seems a bit too... "sophisticate" for CoverGirl - too elegantly old-fashioned, really. I also see some blush here... or maybe that's your skin. I'm really not sold on this at all, Kate. Sorry... :/
Lee: This is very poor. I hate everything about it!
Adele: I think you just redeemed yourself from that horrible Covergirl Ad during your original cycle. The color looks nice on you. I like the styling. I think you looked fun & fresh here. Overall, I like it
Natalie: Katy, you've peaked this week and it's the right week to do it. You look fierce here, and your lips are absolutely gorgeous. Your shiny hair helps bring out your lips- I have no problems with this. Great job!
Amanda: Yeah, let's forget about what happened in cycle 9 here. This most definitely blows that all the way to the end of the universe. Your lips are stealing the show, even with your gorgeous hair being a little too... sparkly, for lack of a better word. Really, your hair almost steals the show, but it doesn't - I really don't have much else to add. It's young, it's fresh, it's easy, it's breezy, it's beautiful, and it's CoverGirl. Congrats on making the finals
Lee: I don't understand all of the love for this to be honest lol. Your eye make-up is very dark and it looks like you have bags under your eyes. Your lips are weird and I hate the random hand on your shoulder. I guess you shouldn't worry if everyone else loves this though.
Adele: What happened to your left arm? It looks like it was twisted or something. Really distract me. But the Advertisement version is really good. I love the color of the lipstick on your lips. The styling is great and you eye-contact is strong. Overall, except the arm, I'm a fan of this photo
Natalie: I agree with Adele; I'm not so much bothered by the hand as I am with the arm. No matter, this is still a great photo because your lips stand out a lot. Your hair made a vast improvement from last time, and you just look like a model in general. Not bad this week, Monica!
Amanda: Good, but not great. Your lips are front and center and that's good news, but that arm is distracting - your nail polished fingertips aren't. I like your hair (yeah you've done this look before xD) and it's definitely suitable for CoverGirl... but that arm. It looks unnatural and... makes it feel a lot less like a makeup ad. This could be better, but it isn't awful!
Lee: This 100% by far the best Covergirl photo this season. How the hell are people annoyed by your arm if nobody was annoyed with Katy's hand? At least this one has a great styling. Obviously going for a sexy look it fits the picture perfectly. I'm angry nobody else loves this like I do!!!!
... I'm glad that we're having a Second Chance this cycle cause you totally proved us that you're way better than what we saw from Cycle 11. Be Sexy. Always!!!
